After a real alert fires, what is worth keeping is why it fired, whether the response was adequate, and whether the threshold should change — not who reacted fastest. Log each real alert in one template: trigger condition, actual impact, actions taken, false-positive or not, and any follow-up rule change.
During review, separate 'noise floor' from 'real signal': a rule that fires repeatedly with no action needed should have its threshold tuned or be removed; a one-off alert with large impact deserves a rehearsal to verify the channel, not a 'resolved' label just because it stayed quiet.
This article covers the discipline of post-alert review only; it makes no compliance judgement about any incident's impact. Record response time as percentiles, not blame; if numbers stayed flat, record that too, without adding alerts or changing direction.