A long-idle list is not worthless, but do not expect one mass send to wake everyone. Pull the dormant segment out and look at it: wrong content, too much frequency, or a signup promise never kept? The cause decides the re-engagement approach.
Test a small value-check on the dormant layer — send one piece tied to what they signed up for and see whether opens and clicks return. Decide from the result whether to continue, lower frequency, or clean up. Record the audience, time, and result of every send during the campaign with an unchanged definition; do not declare success on a single small uptick.
This article covers testing and recording only and decides no one's send. Record re-engagement results as they are, write 'no recovery' when that is the case, without cross-market absolute comparisons; note flat numbers as flat and do not use them to push more sending or a change of direction.